Economy, Markets, Retirement

Market Volatility: How to Navigate as a 401(k) Investor

401k plans, stock market

March 17, 2025

Market volatility is an inherent characteristic of the investment landscape and should be understood as a normal occurrence rather than a signal of fundamental problems within the market or an individual’s 401(k) portfolio. The historical trajectory of financial markets reveals a consistent pattern of both periods of expansion and contraction¹. Downturns, while potentially unsettling, have invariably been followed by periods of recovery and growth over the long term. For individuals investing through a 401(k) plan, it is crucial to remember that this retirement savings vehicle is specifically designed with a long-term investment horizon in mind. Its structure and benefits are intended to help investors accumulate wealth over decades, weathering the natural fluctuations that occur within the market. Recognizing this inherent cyclicality and the long-term nature of a 401(k) can provide a crucial foundation for maintaining a calm and rational approach during periods of market volatility.

Remain Calm During Market Volatility

Time is on Your Side

A significant advantage for the average 401(k) investor is the typically long timeframe until retirement. With many individuals retiring in their early to mid-sixties, as indicated by recent surveys showing an average retirement age of around 62⁷, a substantial investment window often exists for those in their 20s, 30s, and 40s¹³. This extended period allows for the natural smoothing effect of long-term investing to mitigate the impact of short-term market fluctuations. Historical evidence strongly supports the notion that investors who maintain their positions during market downturns are the ones who ultimately reap the rewards of subsequent recoveries¹. Market corrections, defined as declines of 10% or more, have occurred with relative frequency throughout history, yet the market has consistently bounced back¹⁷. Similarly, while bear markets, characterized by drops of 20% or more, can be more severe, their average duration has historically been significantly shorter than the ensuing bull markets¹⁶. For instance, since 1950, the S&P 500 has experienced 13 instances of declines of 20% or more, with an average price decrease of about 33% and an average duration of 338 days. Critically, the bull markets that followed these crashes have tended to be robust and last considerably longer¹. This historical context underscores the importance of viewing market volatility not as a threat to long-term goals, but as a temporary phase within a broader investment journey.

Start and End Date	% Price Decline	Length in Days
September 7, 1929 to November 13, 1929	-44.67	67
April 10, 1930 to December 16, 1930	-44.29	250
February 24, 1931 to June 2, 1931	-32.86	98
June 27. 1931 to October 5, 1931	-43.10	100
November 9, 1931 to June 1, 1932	-61.81	205
September 7, 1932 to February 27, 1933	-40.60	173
July 18, 1933 to October 21, 1933	-29.75	95
February 6, 1934 to March 14, 1935	-31.81	401
March 6, 1937 to March 31, 1938	-54.50	390
November 9, 1938 to April 8, 1939	-26.10	150
October 25, 1939 to June 10, 1940	-31.95	229
November 9, 1940 to April 28, 1942	-34.47	535
May 29, 1946 to May 17, 1947	-28.78	353
June 15, 1948 to June 13, 1949	-20.57	363
August 2, 1956 to October 22, 1957	-21.63	446
December 12, 1961 to June 26, 1962	-27.97	196
February 9, 1966 to October 7, 1966	-22.18	240
November 29, 1968 to May 26, 1970	-36.06	543
January 11, 1973 to October 3, 1974	-48.20	630
November 28, 1980 to August 12, 1982	-27.11	622
August 25, 1987 to December 4, 1987	-33.51	101
March 24, 2000 to September 21, 2001	-36.77	546
January 4, 2002 to October 9, 2002	-33.75	278
October 9, 2007 to November 20, 2008	-51.93	408
January 6, 2009 to March 9, 2009	-27.62	62
February 19, 2020 to March 23, 2020	-33.92	33
January 3, 2022 to October 12, 2022	-25.43	282
Average	-35.24	289

Emotional Investing Leads to Poor Outcomes

Reacting emotionally to market downturns by selling investments can have detrimental effects on long-term returns¹⁹. Selling during a decline essentially crystallizes losses, preventing investors from participating in the subsequent rebound when the market recovers¹⁹. Furthermore, attempting to predict market highs and lows, a strategy known as market timing, is exceedingly challenging, even for professionals with extensive experience and resources²⁰. The unpredictable nature of market movements, influenced by a multitude of factors ranging from geopolitical events to economic indicators, makes consistent and accurate timing virtually impossible²⁵. Studies have shown that even missing a few of the market’s best-performing days can significantly erode overall returns over the long run²⁶. A notable pattern in market behavior is that many of the most substantial gains often occur in the early stages of a recovery, frequently during or shortly after a bear market²⁰. Investors who have exited the market during the downturn risk missing out on these crucial periods of rapid growth, thereby hindering their ability to recover losses and achieve their long-term financial objectives. The tendency for individuals to make investment decisions based on fear and anxiety during market drops can lead to the very outcome they seek to avoid: diminished returns³¹.

Dollar-Cost Averaging Works in Your Favor

For 401(k) investors who contribute a fixed amount of money regularly, often through automatic payroll deductions, a strategy called dollar-cost averaging is inherently at play³⁶. This method involves purchasing more shares of an investment when its price is lower and fewer shares when its price is higher³⁶. During periods of market volatility, when prices decline, consistent 401(k) contributions effectively allow investors to acquire more shares at a reduced cost³⁶. Over time, this practice naturally lowers the average cost basis of the investment portfolio³⁶. Instead of viewing market downturns with trepidation, investors utilizing dollar-cost averaging can recognize that these periods actually present opportunities to accumulate more assets at a lower average price, potentially enhancing their long-term returns when the market eventually recovers³⁶. The systematic nature of regular 401(k) contributions aligns perfectly with the principles of dollar-cost averaging, providing a built-in mechanism to navigate market volatility effectively.

Practical Advice

Review, Don’t React

When faced with market volatility, a prudent approach for 401(k) investors is to use it as a prompt to review their existing asset allocation rather than impulsively making significant changes. It is essential to reassess whether the current mix of investments still aligns with their individual time horizon until retirement and their personal comfort level with risk⁴⁴. Younger investors with a longer runway to retirement might comfortably maintain a higher allocation to equities for potential growth, as they have more time to recover from market dips⁴⁵. Conversely, those nearing retirement might prefer a more conservative allocation with a greater emphasis on bonds and other fixed-income investments to prioritize capital preservation⁴⁵. Instead of drastic portfolio overhauls in response to short-term market noise, consider making small, strategic adjustments if necessary. This might involve rebalancing the portfolio to bring asset class weights back in line with the original target allocation, especially if market movements have caused a significant deviation⁵².

Maintain Proper Diversification

A cornerstone of managing investment risk, particularly during volatile periods, is maintaining a properly diversified portfolio across various asset classes¹⁹. Diversification involves spreading investments across different types of assets, such as stocks, bonds, and potentially other categories like real estate or international markets⁵⁰. The rationale behind this strategy is that different asset classes tend to perform differently under various market conditions¹⁹. When one asset class experiences a downturn, others may hold steady or even appreciate, thereby cushioning the overall impact on the portfolio. For investors who find the task of managing their own asset allocation daunting, target-date funds can be a valuable option⁴⁴. These funds are designed to automatically adjust their asset allocation over time, becoming more conservative as the investor approaches their target retirement date⁴⁴. This hands-off approach provides built-in diversification and asset allocation management tailored to a specific retirement timeline. More active, managed fund options are also available and can in many cases provide even greater returns and diversification benefits more tailored to an investor’s risk appetite, time horizon, and other factors unique to them. Remembering that different asset classes often move independently is key to understanding how diversification helps to mitigate risk.

Age Group	Stocks (%)	Bonds (%)	Cash (%)
Less than 40	100	0.0	0.0
40 to 50	80	20	0.0
51 to 55	70	30	0.0
56 to 60	50	50	0.0
61 to 65 (at 65)	25	75	0.0
20s and 30s	90 – 100	0-10	0.0
40s	80 – 100	0-20	0.0
50s	65 – 85	15 – 35	0.0
60s	30 – 50	40 – 60	0 – 10
70s and over	0 – 20	45 – 65	30 – 50

Focus on What You Can Control

During periods of market volatility, it is empowering for 401(k) investors to concentrate on the aspects of their financial plan that they can directly influence. One of the most impactful actions is to continue making consistent contributions to the 401(k), regardless of market fluctuations. This consistent investment reinforces the benefits of dollar-cost averaging, allowing for the purchase of more shares when prices are lower³⁶. Another crucial step is to ensure that they are maximizing any employer match offered by their company. This matching contribution represents a significant boost to retirement savings and should not be overlooked. If the individual’s financial situation allows, considering a slight increase in their contribution rate during market downturns can be a strategic move to take further advantage of lower prices and potentially accelerate long-term wealth accumulation. By focusing on these controllable factors, investors can maintain a proactive stance towards their retirement goals, even amidst market uncertainty.

Seek Perspective, Not Predictions

In times of market volatility, it is advisable for 401(k) investors to limit their consumption of
financial news. The constant influx of information, often focused on short-term market movements, can amplify anxiety and potentially lead to emotional and ill-advised investment decisions. It is important to remember that financial media often thrives on heightened emotions and sensational headlines, which may not always provide a balanced or long-term perspective. Instead of getting caught up in the daily market noise and speculative predictions, investors should focus on their own well-defined long-term financial plan and retirement objectives. Regularly reviewing these goals and understanding the rationale behind their investment strategy can provide a stable anchor during periods of market turbulence, helping to maintain a rational and disciplined approach.

Historical Evidence of Market Resilience and Recovery

History offers numerous examples of significant market downturns followed by substantial recoveries, illustrating the inherent resilience of the stock market. The Great Depression, commencing with the crash of 1929, witnessed a staggering 79% decline in the stock market, marking the most severe drop in the past 150 years³. While the recovery was protracted, taking over four years to reach its previous peak³, it ultimately demonstrated the market’s capacity to rebound. The dot-com bubble burst in the early 2000s, followed by the Global Financial Crisis of 2008-2009, comprised what is often referred to as the “Lost Decade,” with a cumulative stock market loss of 54%³. The recovery from these events was lengthy, taking over twelve years to reach pre-crash levels³. More recently, the COVID-19 pandemic in early 2020 triggered a sharp but brief market downturn, with the US stock market losing nearly 8% in a single day³. Remarkably, the market recovered from this crash in just four months, the fastest recovery in the past 150 years³. Even the December 2021 market downturn, spurred by geopolitical events and inflation, which saw a 28.5% decline over nine months, was followed by a recovery within 18 months³. Across these diverse historical episodes, the pattern of market decline followed by eventual recovery remains consistent¹⁸. The average recovery period for major US market crashes has been approximately two years, although some, like the recovery after the 1929 crash, took considerably longer⁶⁷. However, more recent downturns, such as the COVID-19 crash, have seen much faster recoveries⁶⁷. Since 1980, the S&P 500 has experienced an average calendar-year decline of about 14%, yet it has typically recovered to finish the year with an average gain of around 13%¹⁷. This historical evidence underscores the temporary nature of market downturns and the long-term upward trajectory of the market.

Conclusion

Market volatility is an unavoidable aspect of investing in a 401(k) and should not be perceived as an anomaly or a cause for undue alarm. The historical performance of financial markets demonstrates a consistent cycle of fluctuations, with downturns invariably followed by periods of recovery and growth. A 401(k) is specifically structured as a long-term investment vehicle, designed to withstand these natural market cycles and facilitate wealth accumulation over an extended period. Remaining calm and avoiding emotional reactions, such as selling during downturns, is crucial for preserving long-term investment success. Strategies like dollar-cost averaging, inherent in regular 401(k) contributions, work to the advantage of consistent investors during volatile times. By focusing on controllable factors like contribution rates and maintaining a well-diversified portfolio aligned with their long-term goals, 401(k) investors can effectively navigate market swings. Seeking a long-term perspective grounded in historical evidence, rather than reacting to short-term predictions and news cycles, is paramount. The historical record clearly indicates that staying the course through market volatility has been the most successful strategy for the vast majority of retirement investors, allowing them to benefit from the market’s long-term upward trend and achieve their financial goals.

Works Cited

Covenantwealthadvisors.com, accessed March 14, 2025
A Brief History of Bear Markets – Investopedia, accessed March 14, 2025
Stock Market Crashes: A Look at 150 Years of Bear Markets …, accessed March 14, 2025
A History of Stock Market Percentage Declines (15% to 50%+), in Charts – Trade That Swing, accessed March 14, 2025
Biggest Stock Market Crashes in History – The Motley Fool, accessed March 14, 2025
List of stock market crashes and bear markets – Wikipedia, accessed March 14, 2025
Nerdwallet.com, accessed March 14, 2025
What is the Average Retirement Age in the US? – Guardian, accessed March 14, 2025
What Is the Average Retirement Age in the US? – NerdWallet, accessed March 14, 2025
Planning to retire at 65? Most Americans stop working years earlier — and not because they want to – CBS News, accessed March 14, 2025
The Average Retirement Age in 2024: US vs. Japan – Nasdaq, accessed March 14, 2025
What is the average retirement age? – Empower, accessed March 14, 2025
Ten Important Facts About 401(k) Plans – Investment Company Institute, accessed March 14, 2025
What Past Stock Market Declines Can Teach Us | Capital Group, accessed March 14, 2025
Understanding Stock Market Corrections and Crashes (2025) – Covenant Wealth Advisors, accessed March 14, 2025
10 Things You Should Know About Bear Markets, accessed March 14, 2025
A game plan for market corrections – Fidelity, accessed March 14, 2025
Guide to stock market recoveries – Capital Group, accessed March 14, 2025
7 Tips on How to Survive in a Bear Market – Merrill Lynch, accessed March 14, 2025
3 Reasons to Not Sell After a Market Downturn – Investopedia, accessed March 14, 2025
Avoiding Wealth Destruction: the Dangers of Selling Low – White Top Investor, accessed March 14, 2025
Stock Market Down? One Thing Never to Do – Investopedia, accessed March 14, 2025
If you’re thinking about selling your stocks, you might want to think twice – AP News, accessed March 14, 2025
Market Timing: What It Is and How It Can Backfire – Investopedia, accessed March 14, 2025
The Illusion Of Market Timing – Forbes, accessed March 14, 2025
Timing the Market Is Impossible – Hartford Funds, accessed March 14, 2025
Market Timing: Opportunities and Risks – CAIA, accessed March 14, 2025
Stock market timing: What it is and why it’s so hard to do – Bankrate, accessed March 14, 2025
Does Market Timing Work? Risks & Alternatives – Britannica Money, accessed March 14, 2025
Principles for Long-Term Investing: Market Timing Does Not Work – Winthrop Wealth, accessed March 14, 2025
New evidence on how investor emotions affect markets, accessed March 14, 2025
The Posited Relationship of Emotional Intelligence to Long-Term Investment Performance – Harvard DASH, accessed March 14, 2025
The Impact of Emotional Finance, and Market Knowledge and Investor Protection on Investment Performance in Stock and Real Estate Markets – Sage Journals, accessed March 14, 2025
(PDF) Emotion and Investment Returns: Situation and Personality as Moderators in a Stock Market – ResearchGate, accessed March 14, 2025
Emotions and Investing – Commerce Bank, accessed March 14, 2025
What Is Dollar-Cost Averaging? Guide for Investors – Merrill Lynch, accessed March 14, 2025
Navigating Market Volatility with Dollar Cost Averaging – ABA Retirement Funds, accessed March 14, 2025
Dollar-Cost Averaging (DCA) Explained With Examples and …, accessed March 14, 2025
Dollar Cost Averaging: A Safeguard Against Market Volatility – Investing.com, accessed March 14, 2025
Dollar-cost averaging: what it means, and will it help me through market volatility?, accessed March 14, 2025
Dollar-Cost Averaging – Innovative CPA Group, accessed March 14, 2025
Dollar-Cost Averaging: A Strategy for Investing in Volatile Markets – eCIO, accessed March 14, 2025
Investing during a down market | How to dollar-cost average – Fidelity, accessed March 14, 2025
401k Asset Allocation Made Simple – 401khelpcenter.com, accessed March 14, 2025
Are your retirement savings benefiting from asset allocation by age? – Jackson, accessed March 14, 2025
How to Manage Your Portfolio’s Asset Allocation at Any Age, accessed March 14, 2025
Troweprice.com, accessed March 14, 2025
Retirement savings by age: What to do with your portfolio in 2025 – T. Rowe Price, accessed March 14, 2025
Choosing Your Retirement Plan Investments: Understanding Risk Tolerance Levels, accessed March 14, 2025
401k Asset Allocation – 401khelpcenter.com, accessed March 14, 2025
What Is Risk Tolerance and How Can You Determine Yours?, accessed March 14, 2025
Asset Allocation Calculator – Portfolio Allocation Models – SmartAsset, accessed March 14, 2025
Pick 401(k) Assets Like a Pro – Investopedia, accessed March 14, 2025
Retirement income strategies – Vanguard Institutional, accessed March 14, 2025
Target-date Fund Glide Path – Vanguard Institutional, accessed March 14, 2025
Generational Changes in 401(k) Behaviors – Vanguard, accessed M
Target Retirement Funds – The Vanguard Group, Inc., accessed March 14, 2025
Asset Allocation: Key to Your Investment Climate – Vanguard, accessed March 14, 2025
Retirement Guidelines – Fidelity, accessed March 14, 2025
How Much do I Need to Retire? – Fidelity Investments, accessed March 14, 2025
Average Retirement Savings By Age – Fidelity Investments, accessed March 14, 2025
Retirement Investing Tips by Age – Fidelity Investments, accessed March 14, 2025
Fidelity Advantage 401(k) Plan Eligible Automatic Contribution Arrangement/Qualified Default Investment Alternative Notice, accessed March 14, 2025
Stock Performance in Every Recession Since 1980 – The Motley Fool, accessed March 14, 2025
What We’ve Learned From 150 Years of Stock Market Crashes – Morningstar, accessed March 14, 2025
How long does it take stock markets to recover from a downturn? – IG Wealth Management, accessed March 14, 2025
Timeline of U.S. Stock Market Crashes – Investopedia, accessed March 14, 2025
Market Declines: A History of Recoveries – MFS Investment Management, accessed March 14, 2025

Subscribe to the Slavic401k Blog

Be the first to know when new content is available.

Market Volatility: How to Navigate as a 401(k) Investor